A Surprise Twist in Stewart’s NFL Journey
Bengals draft pick Shemar Stewart might return to college: Shemar Stewart, the 17th overall pick by the Cincinnati Bengals in the 2025 NFL Draft, is making headlines—not for his performance on the field, but for what might be a dramatic reversal in his career path.
Amid a tense contract dispute with the Bengals, Stewart is reportedly considering a return to college, a move that would shake the very foundations of the NFL’s draft and rookie contract system.
The Controversial Clause Behind the Standoff
At the heart of the dispute is a contract clause introduced by the Bengals. This “default clause” would allow the team to void guaranteed money in Stewart’s contract if he becomes involved in disciplinary or off-field issues.
While similar clauses have been used for later-round picks, it is highly unusual to include one for a first-rounder.
Stewart and his agent have pushed back, stating that the clause is unfair and could put his financial security at risk.
College Comeback or Just Training?
Adding fuel to the speculation, Stewart was recently seen working out at Texas A&M—the college he previously played for—sparking rumors that he may return to college football if the contract situation isn’t resolved.
However, multiple reports have clarified that while Stewart is using the facilities at Texas A&M, he is not training with the team or wearing school colors.
It is common for NFL rookies to return to their college facilities for personal workouts during the offseason.
Still, the mere presence of Stewart on campus has opened the door to questions about whether he is considering opting out of the NFL season or even attempting to regain NCAA eligibility—a legally complex and unprecedented move.
The NCAA & NFL Eligibility Puzzle
Returning to college after declaring for the draft is not straightforward. NCAA regulations typically bar drafted players from rejoining their college teams.
However, legal experts and sports analysts suggest that, in today’s changing environment—with NIL deals, antitrust lawsuits, and increasing athlete rights—there might be loopholes Stewart could explore to regain his eligibility or delay his NFL entry.
This situation has created a unique legal and professional gray area that could have long-term implications for how rookie contracts are negotiated in the future.
What’s Next for Stewart and the Bengals?
The Bengals’ training camp is set to begin on July 23, and Stewart has not yet signed his rookie contract.
If the dispute isn’t resolved soon, Stewart risks delaying his development and missing out on a crucial rookie season.
On the other hand, if the Bengals remain rigid, they risk losing a top defensive prospect for the season—or longer.
Stewart could also request a trade if talks don’t progress or simply wait out the situation in hopes of re-entering the draft in 2026.
Conclusion
Shemar Stewart’s situation is more than just a rookie contract negotiation—it’s a potential turning point in NFL player leverage. Whether he signs with the Bengals, returns to college, or seeks a new path altogether, Stewart’s decision will set a powerful precedent for future athletes navigating the fine print of professional sports contracts. All eyes will be on Cincinnati in the coming days, as one of the NFL’s most promising young talents decides his next move.
